Tidy Cat is offering a new
kitty litter, Tidy Cat Glade Tough Order Solution. Please don’t ever use this. Artificial scents are virtually unregulated
in this country and are the overwhelming source of scent in commercial
products. 95 percent of artificial scent
is toxic. Even natural chemicals can be hazardous.
Women’s Voices for the Earth
tested 20 popular cleaners from 5 top companies. In their words, “We found reproductive
toxins, carcinogens, hormone disruptors, and allergens, and none
of these chemicals were listed on the product label.”
Glade is owned by S.C. Johnson
& Son. In the product Glade Plug In Scented Oil Hawaiian Breeze the
organization found limonene, linalool and eugenol. Limonene and linalook, although natural, are
known to provoke allergic reactions. [1] Eugeneol, the active ingredient in clove oil,
is also used in insecticides.[2]
I would think that the chemicals in the kitty litter would be the same as the ones in the Glade air "freshening" products. You don’t know if your cat is
allergic to limonene or linalool until you expose them to it and you don’t know
how allergic the animal is. If you are
unlucky enough, that one exposure may be too much for your cat. These chemicals are terpenes. There is no known antidote for them. The only treatment is supportive.[3] In
the air terpenes combine with ozone to create formaldehyde, a cancer-causing
chemical with a low acceptable exposure limit[4]
and secondary particles of air pollution whose effects haven’t been determined
yet.[5]
It is possible to consume too much eugenol. In fact the National Library
of Medicine defines eugenol overdose as "poisoning from swallowing a large
amount of eugenol oil (clove oil)." Some of the symptoms are shallow and
rapid breathing, coughing up blood, blood in urine, burns in mouth and throat,
abdominal pain, nausea, rapid heartbeat, dizziness, seizures, and even coma.[6] Clumping kitty litter gets stuck on cat fur,
especially if they have long hair. It is
not a good idea to let your cats ingest this.
In addition to these natural occurring ingredients, the National Resources Defense
Council discovered that Glade Plug-Ins also contain phthalates, chemicals that can
cause endocrine, reproductive, and developmental problems. Regular use of air fresheners increases asthma
30 to 50 percent.[7]
Another possible ingredient is synthetic musk, a potential hormone
disruptor. Synthetic musk increases the
likelihood of breast cancer and liver toxicity.[8] Stanford University researchers Till
Luckenbach and David Epel have also discovered that synthetic musk enhances the
effect of other toxic substances.[9]
Not only would your cat be breathing in and ingesting the above
chemicals, so would anyone else in the dwelling. Do you really want to set yourself up for
future illness by using Tidy Cat Glade kitty litter, or any Glade products?
[1] “Dirty
Secrets Test Results,” Women’s Voices for the Earth, www.womensvoices.org, accessed 28 June
2013.
[3]
John Said Kashani, DO, Asim Tarabar, MD, Steve Marcus, MD, Terpene Toxicity
Medication, Medscape Reference: Drugs, Diseases and Procedures,
emedicine.medscape.com, accessed 28 June 2013.
[4]
Dr. Ben Kim, “Beware of toxic air fresheners,” Chet Day’s Health & Beyond
Online, www.chetday.com, accessed 28 June
2013.
[5] W.
W. Nazaroff, et all, “Final Report:
Contract No. 01-336 Prepared for the California Air Resources Board and
the California Environmental Protection Agency, 10 May, 2006,” Mindfully.org, www.mindfully.org, accessed 28 June 2013.
[6] W.
J. Rayment, Eugenoll, Indepthinfo.com, accessed 28 June 2013.
[7] Dr.
Ben Kim, “Beware of toxic air fresheners,” Chet Day’s Health & Beyond
Online, www.chetday.com, accessed 28 June
2013.
[8] “Synthetic Musks,” The Campaign for Safe Cosmetics, www.safecosmetics.org, accessed on 28
June 2013.
[9] Cynthia Washam, “A Whiff of Danger: Synthetic Musks May Encourage Toxic
Bioaccumulation,” Environmental Health
Perspectives, vol. 113(1), January 2005, U.S. National Library of Medicine,
National Institutes of Health.